The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    Decapolis May 2005/Adelaide
    Adelaide — Over Tired & Ill Prepared cover

    Adelaide

    Over Tired & Ill Prepared

    (2004)

    Reviewed by Jacob Gehman

    DiscogsBandcamp
    Label Word of Mouth RecordsDecapolisMay 2005
    alternative rockemoindie rocksinger-songwriter

    In music, no matter how shallow the concept sounds, it all boils down to a band's name. Consider, for instance, Big Dismal. No one wants to listen to an artist who sounds like a depressed rag, especially in the Christian market. Similarly, no non-southern gospel act should even think about calling themselves The McClurg Family Singers unless they want to spend their life opening for acts like The Martins, The Hagee Family, The Hoppers, and The Booth Brothers.

    As The McClurg Family Singers they (now known as Adelaide) released one album, ...in a Fading Breath, that met with some decent reviews in Christian circles. Their new cd is getting some added attention simply because Adelaide is such a considerable upgrade over their prior band name. In fact for the poetically inclined Adelaide offers a lot of rhyming possibilities. Consider:

    Oh! Hey, here comes Adelaide!
    Not sour like yesterday's lemonade,
    Which can be sipped under lovely shade,
    It's not lonely as an old maid,
    (Who is frail and requiring first aid)
    Indeed they can be her ageless Band-Aid!
    Oh yeah, that is our Adelaide.

    Sadly, the music of Overtired & Ill Prepared does not inspire similar poetic outbursts. While it is performed solidly enough, the songwriting feels tired and uninspired. Only half way through the album starts to get rather boring. The decent tracks are reminiscent of a less energized, less emotional The Evan Anthem. The rest of the album is merely skip-worthy filler we've heard before from countless indie rock bands, though it is fitting in context of the rest of the album.

    If you are a fan of the genre, you may find enough interesting tracks to warrant the purchase, especially if you only feel comfortable with Christian music. Otherwise, there is no real reason to bother checking this album out. Unless, that is, you are planning on needing to rhyme something with "outrageously underpaid" in the not too distant future.

    2/4

    Other coverage for this album

    HM Magazine #114Reviewed by Amy E. HallFor those us of who enjoy getting to know the bands and artists we listen to, good luck cracking the code to this one. Buffalo, New York-based band Adelaide appears to relish ambiguity. Offering little but the first name and last initial of each band member, it would seem that the quintet prefers to remain somewhat anonymous, without so much as a squeak as to who plays what instrument. Further,…The Phantom Tollbooth 2005Reviewed by Kerry MaffeoOn the surface, Adelaide seems to be yet another independent modern rock band trying to make it on the main stage. A deeper look, however, reveals a thought-provoking lyrical base and melodic driving piano and guitar musical mix. There's more to these Buffalo, NY guys than meets the eye! Although earning themselves critical acclaim in the rock community as The McClurg Family Singers, the band…

    Similar sounding releases

    2005El ToroMay and Marielle2002CadetThe Observatory2000VerbowWhite Out2003CopelandBeneath Medicine Tree2003Cool Hand LukeWake Up, O Sleeper2005The Evan AnthemSens

    Also in Decapolis May 2005

    2005El ToroMay and Marielle2004Amusement Parks On FireAmusement Parks On Fire2005ShindigThis Beginning is Your End2005MillencolinKingwood2005RamonesEnd of the Century: The Story of the Ramones (Video)2005Colonel RhodesThis Is Public