The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2005/Aly & AJ
    Aly & AJ — Into the Rush cover

    Aly & AJ

    Into the Rush

    (2005)

    Reviewed by Jamie Lee Rake

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Hollywood RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2005
    dance poppoppop rock

    Teen sisters Aly and AJ Michalka are among the elite of young actresses/singers who owe their careers to a certain, late Uncle Walt. After starring in shows and specials on the cable's Disney Channel and airplay on Radio Disney with songs from their projects' soundtracks, the gals have a whole album to themselves.

    It turns out the alliteratively monikered siblings are Christians, but only recently has anything from their debut, Into the Rush, been officially offered to Christian radio. For anyone naming Zoegirl and Kelly Clarkson among their current favorites, the Michalkas offer another potential fave.

    As it turns out, the spirituality expressed by the sisters finds the middle ground between cultural Christendom's most prominent blonde&brunette trio and the first American Idol winner. Both of the aforementioned acts are so ubiquitous in their respective markets that it almost seems redundant to describe Aly & AJ's sound afterwards.

    Suffice it to say that they haven't navigated the pendulous arc of Clarkson's emotive breadth (evident in her single releases thus far). Neither do they sound as evangelighetto wimpy (or kitsch?) as the Zoe'sters on a bad day. What these girls do to distinguish themselves is write songs that, more than anything else about it, hint at their faith (like current Christian radio single "Rush") or get a little more explicit about social concerns (missing children on "I Am One Of Them"), fledgling romance ("Something More") or the quandaries of teen angst. All clean, shinily produced and possessed of the thinnest glint of an edge.

    When they aren't singing their own work, their handlers have fed them cover versions for their soundtrack gigs. Included here are their nearly karaoke-alike take on The Lovin' Spoonful's "Do You Believe In Magic" (an overrated song, anyway, in my estimation) and Katrina & The Waves' "Walking On Sunshine." As for the latter, the original's buoyant horn charts are kept intact, and the first time I heard it on the notoriously non-back announcing Radio Disney, I could have sworn it was by Jump5. That, by the way, is a compliment.

    Though the musicality behind Aly & AJ could be tweaked to give them a more distinctive flavor, Into the Rush's fortified bubblegum could have been plenty worse. That's another way to say "Promising start, girls, but..."

    3 tocks

    Similar sounding releases

    2005Kara WilliamsonUndisguised2004EverlifeEverlife2002Avril LavigneLet Go2005Sarah BrendelSarah Brendel2002Rebecca St. JamesWorship God2005Bethany DillonImagination

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2005

    2004Carolyn ArendsChristmas An Irrational Season2004EvanescenceAnywhere but Home2004The KryGod of Infinite Worth2005Promise KeepersThe Awakening2004EverlifeEverlife2003Catharsis and the HumdrumCatharsis and the Humdrum