The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    Decapolis May 2005/Blessed By A Broken Heart
    Blessed By A Broken Heart — All Is Fair In Love And War cover

    Blessed By A Broken Heart

    All Is Fair In Love And War

    (2004)

    Reviewed by Evan Stanek

    DiscogsYouTube
    Label Blood & Ink RecordsDecapolisMay 2005
    grindcorehardcoreheavy metalmetalcore

    Maybe some but not all of you are familiar with the movie "Saw". For the uninformed, Saw is basically a movie about a guy who is tired of people not appreciating how good their lives really are. So this sicko puts some people into precarious life minus limbs or death situations where individuals are forced to chop of their hand or saw off a leg or some other disgusting maneuver in order for them to keep their lives, which they will hopefully appreciate a little more after looking death in the face.

    If there was a sequel to this movie, except rather than life, the object of appreciation was music, you could picture a scene somewhat like this. Its of me...sitting in a room...listening to this CD with a pair of headphones duct taped to my head and a chainsaw in the corner which, if I'm careful enough, could cut through the tape just enough to remove the music. One foul move, and (see track #5), you get the picture. The movie would end with me being scarred for life by what I heard, but appreciating the music I know and love that much more. Of course this is a gross exaggeration, and no music could really be that bad...

    Don't get me wrong, I like hard music, and someone out there may enjoy this. But I could not take this band seriously when the first song features a cheesy classic metal riff, the falsetto singing towards the end of "That Knife Ain't for Butter" made me want to harm myself, the fourth track "The Devil is the Don's" impressive slide ridden start with machine gun drumming grinds to a halt by the end, the vocals at large dirty and transparent, and Mic Skillz actually features somebody screaming the ABC's up through the letter G. I tried, I really did.

    Some bands like "He is Legend" can at times get away with this sassiness, but Blessed by a Broken heart didn't earn any of my respect before taking that direction with this album. Fans of more metal than core metal core may find something here. Everybody else, stay away.

    Other coverage for this album

    HM Magazine #114Reviewed by Tiffany ChowFrom its onset, Blessed By A Broken Heart’s first full-length is clearly constructed to cast lasting impressions on its listeners, first or long time fans. The opening track, entitled “Action,” is not much of a track at all. Consisting of a solid metal guitar lick and a sample, the first track does an adequate job of launching the genre-relevant but tastefully innovative All Is Fair In Love And…

    Similar sounding releases

    2005Pale HorseUntil the Last Seal Is Opened...1997Screams of ChaosGenetic War2005Living SacrificeIn Memoriam2004Society's FinestLove, Murder, and a Three-Letter Word1999UnderoathAct of Depression1993ParamaeciumExhumed of the Earth

    Also in Decapolis May 2005

    1980The CureSeventeen Seconds2005Hank JonesSaturdays Of Thunder2005Des ArkLoose Lips Sink Ships2005MaeThe Everglow2005Amber PacificThe Possibility and the Promise2005The Aquabats!Charge!!