The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2005/Critical Mass
    Critical Mass — Grasping for Hope in the Darkness cover

    Critical Mass

    Grasping for Hope in the Darkness

    Reviewed by Freddie Odom

    Apple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotify
    Label independentThe Phantom Tollbooth2005
    alternative rockccmhard rock

    I first heard of Critical Mass a few years ago when, out of curiosity, I typed "Catholic Rock Band" into Google. However, I admit that I didn't listen to any of their music until today.

    The band definitely has a lot of artistic merit...this entire album is based on the Grasping for Hope in the Darkness comic book, which is available on the band's website. The comic book, drawn in pencil by bandmember David Wang, is actually what we would refer to as a "tract" in evangelical Protestantism. (The difference is: unlike Jack Chick's infamously scary tracts, David Wang does not appear to hate Catholicism.)

    The band is also a friend of literacy (the second track on the album is based on the book Dorian Gray, according to the liner notes) and really wants to make a point. Throughout the album, they do battle with: pornography, explicit lyrics, the legality of abortion, sex education, condoms, the abuse scandal in the Catholic church, judgmentalism, the Jesus Seminar, and... leftist Christian politicians?

    Not only did they do all of that; they managed to fit music onto the CD as well. The music sounds very much like CCM, and it is... a lot of it was written for World Youth Day, a Canadian youth conference. However, I've been waiting for a Christian band to cover "Carry On Wayward Son." They did it, and your band didn't.

    Overall, a very strong effort.

    4 tocks

    Similar sounding releases

    2005Audio AdrenalineUntil My Heart Caves In2005Sister HazelLift2000One Hundred DaysThe Super Terrific Happy Hour2004LiveAwake: The Best of Live2005Grand PrizeIdentity2002Daily PlanetHero

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2005

    2005Greg AdkinsLower Than the Angels2005Ben HulburtActivate2005ChristafariGravitational Dub2005Global WarningEnemy Within2004The Ned Kelly BandSongs From the Book of Life2005Scratch TrackUnreleased Sessions