The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2003/Derek Webb
    Derek Webb — She Must and Shall Go Free cover

    Derek Webb

    She Must and Shall Go Free

    (2003)

    Reviewed by Brian A. Smith

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label INO RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2003
    americanafolk rocksinger-songwriter

    I have a wish. I wish that INO Records, the label of Sara Groves, Michael Card, Sonicflood, and now Derek Webb does not go the way of Sprint Records. I don't want them to get bought by a larger conglomerate, or deal with budget concerns, or go the way of a thousand other promising labels. I just want them to keep signing and developing artists who release albums even half as good as Groves' All Right Here or Derek Webb's new release, She Shall and Must Go Free.

    Webb's first solo effort after leaving Caedmon's Call, the album focuses, in Webb's words, "a record about what Jesus loved - the Church". He does not shy away from the failings of the Church's inhabitants, pointing them out in "Beloved," an indictment of false prophets; portraying them as an adulterous bride in "Wedding Dress," yet also seeing them from the eyes of Christ in "Lover."

    "Nobody Loves Me," very much in the mode of Keith Green lyrically, is the first track, and grabs the listener by painting a picture of a prophet whose job is to point out sin for what it is:

    The truth is never sexy
    So it's not an easy sell
    You can dress her like the culture
    But she'll shock 'em just as well

    "Awake My Soul" is based on Ezekiel 16, and as good an Americana style tune as anything in music today. "Nothing (Without You)" creates a style of its own, sounding like Mitch McVicker singing the blues. "Saints and Sinners" combines country twang with blues guitar. "Crooked Deep Down" rips away our facades, revealing the ugly, inner nature that somehow lurks within us all at times.

    "The Church", which features Sara Groves, describes what Rich Mullins called "the reckless, raging fury that they call the Love of God," demonstrating Christ's pursuit of His bride, seemingly without explanation or a good reason:

    I have long pursued her
    As a harlot and a whore
    But she will feast upon me
    She will drink and thirst no more

    With many quality guests (Jars of Clay, Sandra McCracken) and outstanding songwriting, She Shall and Must Go Free is my early nominee for album of the year. Webb achieves a rarity in music by producing a superior solo effort to that of his former group's recordings.

    5 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    The Rebel Base 2003Reviewed by Andree Farias"And you cannot care for Me, with no regard for her; / If you love Me, you will love the church." She Must and Shall Go Free is a testament to the church. But not the church with the pretty lights and the flashy worship services. Not the one whose notoriety is measured by its colorful TV personalities or deep-seated involvement in politics. Not even the one that's renowned for its hearty amen's…

    Similar sounding releases

    2003Jars of ClayWho We Are Instead2005Glen PhillipsWinter Pays for Summer2004Caedmon's CallChronicles1998Mitch McVickerMitch McVicker2004Justin McRobertsIntersections2000Michael McDermottLast Chance Lounge

    More from Derek Webb

    2005How to Kill and Be Killed (Video)2004I See Things Upside Down2004The House Show

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2003

    2003Next In LineTraffic2002Half-Handed CloudWe Haven't Just Been Told, We Have Been Loved2002Will KimbroughHome Away2003Stretch Arm StrongEngage2003Dust Eater DogsHardbiter's Inn2003YogiSalve