The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2003/Fingerless

    Fingerless

    You Are Not at Risk

    (2003)

    Reviewed by Brian A. Smith

    Label independentThe Phantom Tollbooth2003
    indie rocksinger-songwriter

    Fingerless is Ian Donnell Arbuckle, a 19 year-old college senior who admits to suffering from being clinically depressed. This condition adds some extra substance to his music and poetry - knowing the perspective that goes into some of the lyrics.

    "Restraining Angels" portrays God watching the crucifixion of His Son. It evokes a heartbreaking picture of God telling the angels Michael and Gabriel that they cannot act, that they cannot intervene in this, the cruelest act in human history. The tune then closes with the Father asking the angels to hold back His own hand, so that the horrible work of Christ may be finished.

    "A Road to Run" is a convicting piece about the guilt we bear for the death of Christ. It asks the question of us from Christ: "Will you kill me again?" "Doldrums" shows a man who can see the cure for his problems, yet is helpless to act in such a way to embrace the solution. "Drawn" pleads for hope, the idea that though its subject is imperfect, he is the way he is supposed to be because God wanted him to be that way.

    Arbuckle's vocals are plaintive and sometimes hesitant, but their conviction is rock solid. This EP is disturbing, pleading, and painful in that it strips away our veneer to reveal our worst nature to God, which He already knows. It also shows the way in which we do not feel that way any longer. It remains to be seen if Fingerless is the beginning of something great, or if it is a one time effort. I can only hope that the spirit of the artist here does not get crushed, or masked behind drugs, or otherwise
    blunted.

    4 tocks

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2003

    2002The KryUndone2002Last Tuesday / CurbsquirrelsComposition2002Jason MrazWaiting for My Rocket to Come2003Viva VoceLovers, Lead the Way!2003The FranchiseOriginal Inevitable2003TrickyVulnerable