The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2005/Forgiven 5
    Forgiven 5 — He Is Alive cover

    Forgiven 5

    He Is Alive

    (2004)

    Reviewed by Tom MacMillan

    Apple MusicSpotify
    Label Risen Son RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2005
    classic rockhard rock

    Forgiven 5 is a hard rock group which recorded their debut album, He Is Alive, in 2004. To say that they need a little improvement would be an understatement; the poor quality of their debut is partly due to the production, but much of the work involves the musical development of Forgiven 5.

    By the end of the album, the listener is crying for something different. Forgiven 5 uses similar introductions to each song: a clean electric guitar plays a minor chord with a chorus effect, with the bass playing the three notes of the chord from fifth to root. The arrangements are incredibly cliché, so derivative of '70's hard rock that it is difficult to take the album seriously. An absolutely pathetic attempt to rap ("On My Side") delivers the final blow to the record. Coupled with ridiculous leads and overall lack of originality, He Is Alive has little to offer musically, save the excellent (if not badly recorded) percussion of Thomas McEniry. Despite all this, it is hard not to rock out to "Forevermore," the opening track.

    The production is low-budget and inadequate. Guitars are overdistorted, vocals are constantly off, and keyboards are (at times) distastefully cheesy.

    However, the only goal of Forgiven 5 is to "glorify God and bring lost souls to Christ," and I believe they may do just that. While the group needs to tighten musically and improve intonation, along with recording quality, for their next album, the sound they are aiming toward is clear. Forgiven 5 are just not at that point yet, but any listener can hear their potential.

    1.5 tocks

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2005

    2005Various ArtistsElektra: The Album1997London Philharmonic OrchestraKashmir: The Symphonic Led Zeppelin2005Lost DogsIsland Dreams2005RivieraAt the End of the American Century...2005Back Porch PilgrimsKings of Cannelburg Road2005Scott GrimesLivin' on the Run