The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1999/Mack the Coffee Man
    Mack the Coffee Man — Light Pours Through cover

    Mack the Coffee Man

    Light Pours Through

    (1999)

    Reviewed by Justin W. Jones

    DiscogsBandcamp
    Label Burnt Toast VinylThe Phantom Tollbooth1999
    emoindie rockpost-rock

    Mack, The Coffee Man must be drinking de-caf. This album lacks all the jitters, on the edge, biting-your-fingernails hyperactivity that normally comes from caffeine. Instead, when you hear them, you are listening to a relaxed indie rock album with a touch of emo -- stirred, not shaken. The result is a good album.

    I have heard of this band before because they have played with other great indie rock groups like Pedro the Lion and Joe Christmas, so I was expecting something similar. But their sound is all their own, which is good because familiarity breeds contempt.

    "Light Pours Through" is actually two of their EPs together on one disc. It's a split CD, and each part has its own sound (the first part is more emotional).

    Their sound package is totally unique. It's minimalistic indie rock with occasional guitar solos and a whiny, wispy lead voice. The three guys play together real tight and are blended real well. Their melodies are bittersweet, and the singing causes depression... but a good kind of depression. At times you think you are listening to Bono from U2 sing, but then as it goes on you hear the "whine" in his voice and remember that this is Mack, the Coffee Man.

    There were a few songs on the album that were annoying. I thought the songs didn't have much of a direction and repeated the melody too much, but that was only on two songs. As for the rest, they were good. There was also an ever-present sense that these guys listen to '80s music a whole lot. I really felt that influence in the music and singing.

    The best song on the first split, "Light Pours Through," is "Years." This song has a sad beginning, middle, and end, but it sounds so right. The guitar solo at the end took me back a few years to the age of big hair, Atari, and Glam, when Reagan was in office and the only rock I heard was from my older brother's tape case. It ends the song on a killer groove, and I put my CD player on repeat for a while after I heard it.

    The best song on the second split and my favorite overall was "Estella." I liked this song a lot. It's really up-tempo and sounds a whole lot like Robert Smith and Bono singing at the same time. I'm not saying that this group copies others, just that they will bring those other groups to mind when you hear them. They really bust out with the indie rock style on this song, and it's a song worth hearing on an album worth getting.

    I think Mack the Coffee Man is a good, emotional, dark indie group, and I recommend them to those who like that style. But I need to give you a word of advice: Don't listen to the album after a hard break up, because it might drive you to drinking...espresso.

    4 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    Bandoppler 1999Reviewed by Treble BandopplerI have not written a review in a couple months, because I have been too busy being a hot-shot music writer and Super-Editor, thinking I'm too big and bad to write reviews. But yesterday I was brutally reminded of why I got started in this whole music writing jazz. Mack, The Coffee man! O man, I remember the love, it's all coming back to me. The music, the passion, the artistry, the humility, the…Decapolis 1999Reviewed by TimCreative, but just not as catchy as it could be. My guess is that the next record these guys do will be great. This is still worth buying. C+Decapolis 1999Reviewed by ConradVery creative. Great mixture of artsyness, melody and emotion. Highly highly emotional and deep. Some parts are amazingly emotional. Can I fit the word emotional in here again? Yes I can, emotional. BDecapolis 1999Reviewed by dmkOne of the last remaining gems of the early Lancaster scene, Mack brings their live show talents to the studio with a passionate collection of songs that have enough raw energy to fuel a rocket. They blast off with concert favorites and lots of brand new stuff. While it may take forever for a Mack disc to be released, it is definitely worth the wait. If you are looking for a comparison to another…Decapolis 1999Reviewed by Tom / Jim ShadyMack, the Coffee Man is a three piece indie rock band from Lancaster PA, who have been around for about the past 5 1/2 years.. This new album is interesting in that its a split LP with, well, themselves. Their original intention was to release two separate EP's, that were recorded at two separate studios, with two somewhat different sounds. We are glad that they decided to put both EP's onto one…

    Similar sounding releases

    1998DumpsterSee Through Me2002EeFor 100 We Try HarderAnnie QuickBigger1996The BonhoeffersThanks to Jen1996Fluffy / PhantasmicFluffy vs. Phantasmic2004AveoBattery

    More from Mack the Coffee Man

    1997Every Blessing Tonight

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1999

    1998Sam PhillipsZero Zero Zero1999Kill RatioKill Ratio1998Vigilantes of Love'Cross the Big Pond1999Julie MillerBroken Things1998DiscernRevive and Rebuke1999Various ArtistsIsaiah 53:5 (A Tribute To Stryper)