The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998/MiD

    MiD

    Fresh Evidence

    (1998)

    Reviewed by James Stewart

    Label independentThe Phantom Tollbooth1998
    celtic rockclassic rockrock

    A young, enthusiastic band from Scotland ("aged between 15 and 17 and Scott, who is slightly older.") whose presentation and advertising are extremely promising. Musically this is classic rock, with the odd Celtic twist thanks to guest musician Simone Welsh's violin.

    The lead vocals are male and show the Springsteen, Dylan, and Kevin Prosch influences that Scott Nicol claims. Most of the time Naomi Ballance's vocals accompany Nicol's. The one exception is "Come Home," which is sung by Daniel Robinson, who has more soulful, but softer vocals. All three vocalists show a lot of potential, and I look forward to hearing them grow.

    The lyrics are really where this recording falls down; the band's enthusiasm to share their faith comes through strongly, but the lyrics lack maturity. The music too could do with a stronger focus and needs to move further from their influences.

    The music shows promise, but they could really do with a whole new set of songs. Hopefully now that this is recorded, the experience will allow the band to move on.

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1998

    1998BleachStatic1998PlaidUnderstanding God1995Various ArtistsMy Utmost for His Highest (Video)2000The Mustard SeedsRed1996Kemper CrabbA Medieval Christmas1997CreedMy Own Prison