The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2003/One Good Man

    One Good Man

    Demo

    (2003)

    Reviewed by Greg Adams

    Label independentThe Phantom Tollbooth2003
    countryhard rockheavy metal

    Although the names of powerhouse rockers Robert Plant, Sammy Hagar and Bono are dropped in the liner notes as influences for One Good Man's vocalist Bryan Nydegger, their three-song demo begins with what sounds like a modern country ballad. Over a repeating acoustic guitar line, he sings (very Tim McGrawishly): "When was the last time I said, 'I love you?' / I can't remember when it was / When was the last time that I hugged you? / I can't remember when it was...." The mayhem of distorted guitars and driving drums that crashes down after such a placid, "downhome" intro is incredibly disorienting.

    Heavy metal (including undeveloped, simplistic, couplet-rhyming lyrics) reigns for the next two tracks, but again the smooth, countryish vocal delivery sticks out like a well-pressed denim shirt in the midst of a black leather mosh pit.

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2003

    2003John MayerAny Given Thursday2003Paul Colman TrioOne2003DogwoodSeismic2003Over the RhineOhio2003Todd AgnewGrace Like Rain2003Glenn HansenHim