The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998/Pensive
    Pensive — The Subtlety of Silence cover

    Pensive

    The Subtlety of Silence

    (1997)

    Reviewed by Tony LaFianza

    DiscogsYouTube
    Label 2 Jake RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth1998
    emohardcoremetalcorethrash metal

    Pensive is one of the founding bands on the new label 2 Jake Records, a division of Grrr Records and also new home to Crashdog. 2 Jake Records has hopes of competing with Tooth and Nail, putting out hard music with a lot of ministry in mind. To that end, 2 Jake has signed Pensive out of Pennsylvania. These four young men have written and recorded some interesting music for their debut. The musicianship is here; with high-grade guitar playing by Brett Deter (who is also Zao's new guitarist) and a talented rhythm section of Martin Lunn on bass and Joshua Walters behind the drums. Chad Monticue is the band's vocalist.

    It was Chad's singing style on the subtlety of silence that interested me. When I saw the band live, I was a bit surprised to discover that Chad does all the vocals, because on the record there are two styles of singing. One is a nice singing voice that carries the songs with good tone and pleasant, although alternative, sound. The other is a death metal scream. Sometimes Chad switches between the two styles in the same line.

    Pensive has come up with a distinctive sound by melting several styles together, including thrash, hard core, alternative and praise music. (When I saw them live, they did a new Glenn Kaiser-penned praise song from his Grrr release Throw Down Your Crowns.) The energetic music drives this band's songs while the melodies slowly bounce between two and, sometimes, three notes per song. This has the unfortunate effect of making the vocals seem a bit tedious. The saving grace for this record is the intermix of the rough screamer and the smooth songster playing with these wistful song lines.

    The record ends with about fifteen minutes of beach sounds (waves washing up on shore and sea gulls crying into the ocean breeze) followed by the last notes on the record: backwards guitar. Is it a ponderous, meditative or even pensive juncture? Were they aiming at a Beatles' White Album-like effect? Perhaps, but I think they should wait until they have recorded their Sgt. Pepper's... first. Pensive has succeeded in coming up with an interesting musical style, one that could go in several directions. I, for one, look forward to their sophomore release to see where Pensive heads from here.

    3 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    Dead Zine 1997Reviewed by CeebThis is a very interesting and challenging album to review due to the complexity of the music and the different styles that are played. This six song debut is powerful and technical, and brings the style of hardcore-metal and contemporary to a screeching collision. Only once have I ever heard such a combination of vocals used together, and that was from a secular band called "Crayola Death",…

    Similar sounding releases

    2003Sons Of ThunderCircus Of Power1999OutcryHope for the Torn Heart1991Galactic CowboysGalactic Cowboys2003MortificationPower, Pain & Passion1997LifelessForward to Suffering1995Sweet NectarTired Face in Clown Paint

    More from Pensive

    1998The Psalms of Ariana

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1998

    1998Rev. Milton Brunson's Thompson Community SingersFifty Blessed Years1996TripDancing About Architecture1998JamesThe Best Of1998PolarboyBack From Nowhere Radio Special Disc1996Benjamin AntellIn the Bag1995Mannheim SteamrollerChristmas in the Aire