The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 2004/Various Artists
    Various Artists — Salt Lady Records: Extra Credit cover

    Various Artists

    Salt Lady Records: Extra Credit

    (2003)

    Reviewed by Brian A. Smith

    Discogs
    Label Salt Lady RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth2004
    folk rockindie rockpop rocksinger-songwriter

    I can't stop listening to this disc. Being the fan that I am of Jonathan and Bruce Rundman and Beki Hemingway, I was salivating when I heard about the release of Extra Credit. And I was not disappointed. The Rundman cousins, and the incredibly underrated Hemingway appear on 18 of the 22 tracks on this disc.

    Lest you think this CD a Rundman vanity project, rest assured there is quality here. "No More Walls" is a new recording featuring Beki Hemingway's backup vocals. Hemingway is also featured in "Mary Alice," a song she wrote and sang for This Train, and on "Better Vision," from her album Words for Loss of Words. She and Jonathan Rundman also perform a new song called "Everything to Everyone," which may be the highlight of the album. When are these two going to record a full length disc together?

    Other new tunes include "Omaha" (Bruce & Jonathan Rundman), "Packing Tape" (Bruce), "The Serious Kind" (Jonathan), and "Beige Slacks" (both). All of these live up to the albums they have released. Jeff Krebs contributes "For the Birds," and Todd Miller adds "I Am the Tide."

    The only real miss here for me is the inclusion of Echelon's "Renegade" from Too Much Time on Our Hands, the label's Styx tribute album. With so much material to work with on that album, there were better choices than this particular song. In all, though, Extra Credit lives up to its name ­ these artists deserve much more credit and recognition than they normally receive.

    4.5 tocks

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 2004

    2004MercyMeUndone2004Michael PowersOnyx Root2004Heidi TalbotDistant Future2003Jake ArmerdingJake Armerding2004Various ArtistsAbsolute Smash Hits2004Various ArtistsIn the Name of Love