The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1999/Amy Grant
    Amy Grant — A Christmas To Remember cover

    Amy Grant

    A Christmas To Remember

    (1999)

    Reviewed by James Stewart

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALSpotify
    Label Word RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth1999
    adult contemporaryccm

    Given all the publicity she's been receiving recently, what Amy Grant really needs is a stunning new album to get all the critics talking about something other than her private life. Perhaps a simple Christmas album, with a few simply arranged tunes to follow-up her last regular release. It seems someone got some wires crossed.

    Grant's down to earth voice is strong here, but that's about all that is. The lyrics here collected seem unnecessarily burdened with the consumerist aspect of Christmas music, and the more creditable pieces are marred by overproduction.

    This album really wouldn't seem out of place in a department store's playlist for the pre-Christmas period. There are plenty of lush strings and bouncy tunes, but the moments where something with more merit than the usual cheesy Christmas fare arises are few and swamped by the rest of the album. This wasn't a wise release for Grant.

    1 tock

    Similar sounding releases

    1998Twila ParisPerennial: Songs For The Seasons Of Life2004Sandi PattyHymns of Faith...Songs of Inspiration2001Jaci VelasquezChristmas1998Michael W. SmithChristmastime2002Joni MitchellTravelogue2001Margaret Becker / Maire Brennan / Joanne HoggNew Irish Hymns

    More from Amy Grant

    1994House of Love1997Takes A Little Time2005Rock of Ages...Hymns and Faith1997Behind The Eyes1983A Christmas Album1992Home for Christmas

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1999

    1996Various ArtistsModification: A Tribute to Steve Rowe and MortificationThe Violet BurningThe Violet Burning Demonstrates Plastic and Elastic1999Various ArtistsPlastiq Musiq New Musiq Volume 1.1999CreedHuman Clay1998PJ HarveyIs This Desire?1987Keith GreenThe Ministry Years Volume 1 - 1977-1979