The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998/Beauty for Ashes

    Beauty for Ashes

    Black Fades

    (1998)

    Reviewed by Josh Spencer

    Label independentThe Phantom Tollbooth1998
    experimentalfolk rockgothic rock

    This is an exciting time for underground music, if you like all things eclectic, experimental, and funky-cool. There are a lot of bands--Burlap to Cashmere, Spinoza, Stickman Jones, etc. --drawing from various influences and cultures and bringing in horns, strings, percussion, and so on to create innovative new music. Six-member Beauty For Ashes (two women, four men) is right there with this debut. Their melancholy sound, while original, should bring up a number of appealing associations for some. The male lead vocals are a cross between Mike Knott's low voice and the slightly trembling nasality of Breakfast with Amy's lead singer, for example, and several songs recall the more accessible tracks from Havalina Rail Co.'s latest, especially with the female vocals. The overall sound is scratchy psychedelic meets goth meets moody modern rock meets Eastern European ethnic stuff. Throw in lots of cello, violin, tambourine, clarinet, and bassoon, and it is a musical potpourri, fragrant to some and pungent to others. The lyrics are quite solemn and yearning with many straight Old Testament Scripture references mixed with worshipful poetry. The production is sparse but adequate. Some will find this to be like Havalina--an interesting but too-strange listen--while others will gush for hours. Either way, this is a cool album and a good start. A more polished, mature full-length will be waited for with bated breath.

    4 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998Reviewed by Steven S. BaldwinBassoon solos don't sell. That doesn't bode well for Beauty for Ashes, regrettably. They are the kind of band that is as likely to break into a violin solo, or some other instrument uncommon to rock and roll, as they are to crank out a standard guitar one. Everyone knows that violin solos just don't sell albums. Pity. This is one record worth checking out for just that reason. In the now classic…

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1998

    1998Kosmos ExpressSimulcast1998Pearl JamYield1998Various ArtistsDownstream: A WeatherVane Compilation1998Kevin ProschReckless Mercy1998LSUDogfish Jones1997Havalina Rail Co.Russian Lullabies