The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998/Bumblepuppy
    Bumblepuppy — An Evening at the Feelies cover

    Bumblepuppy

    An Evening at the Feelies

    (1998)

    Reviewed by Josh Spencer

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Bulletproof MusicThe Phantom Tollbooth1998
    alternative rockart rockmodern rockrock

    It's a shame about the name because I have a feeling it's going to keep this band's mood masterpiece in the underground. I only heard the album by accident, having ignored it the few times I'd seen it (I thought it was children's music). Turns out the name comes from a novel the band members are all fond of (Brave New World), but that doesn't help much.

    Anyway, the music is superbly moody modern rock, approaching brilliance at times as it shines a light down the same dark pathways as Radiohead, the Verve, Bloomsday, even the Choir. Listening to this on headphones, I often felt as though I had entered another universe. A place of lush melody and emotion, warm guitars, quietly throbbing bass, and an atmosphere that's alive! There is much variety in the vocals--way back in the mix, "normal," distorted, soft-spoken, upbeat...you get it.

    Interesting song titles ("Nancy Meets Nostradamus," "The Insane Protagonist," "My Supercountry") and lyrics reflect the band's interest in literature and take some effort to interpret (but they still sound cool even to people like me who can't figure them out). Here's an easy excerpt, though:

    As free form as she always wasn't
    She took this as defeat
    But in her mind's eye she saw him hanging
    Suspended by his feet
    Broken and bloodied by the tireless room
    Water flowed from his side
    She lurched and she shook under his steady gaze
    Her heart washed in the tide
    (from "Dead Room")

    (I apologize to the band for probably ruining the meaning by taking them out of the song's context)

    The last track, "Time Must Have a Stop," is from the viewpoint of a man dying in a hospital bed. It's a heartbreaker. Melancholy vocals, sad piano background, heartbeat and monitor sounds, and a breathing machine work together to produce one of the most moving songs I've heard. Tears, man.

    Don't let the name Bumblepuppy scare you away because this is powerful stuff.

    4.5 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    HM Magazine #72Reviewed by Brian Vincent McGovernWith a partiality toward the ethereal, and some nice orchestrations, Bumblepuppy also reels in some respectable guitar work. And lyrics are generally artistic, if not completely indecipherable, and each sonic element is crystal clear. Jared Siebert's whispery vocals seem to invite the listener to sit back, relax, and think. What I like best is the semi-unique instrumentation. While nothing jumps…

    Similar sounding releases

    1996Poor Old LuA Picture of the Eighth Wonder1996Fluffy / PhantasmicFluffy vs. Phantasmic1996The KryWhat About Now1995Spooky TuesdayIt'll Never Fly Orville!1995Adam AgainPerfecta1995The WaitingBlue Belly Sky

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1998

    1998Kevin ProschReckless Mercy1998Aunt BettysFord Supersonic1998Robin MarkThis City These Streets1998Various ArtistsLethal Injection1997RadioheadOK Computer1996Kemper CrabbA Medieval Christmas