The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1997/Disciple
    Disciple — My Daddy Can Whip Your Daddy cover

    Disciple

    My Daddy Can Whip Your Daddy

    (1997)

    Reviewed by Josh Spencer

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Warner ResoundThe Phantom Tollbooth1997
    grungehard rock

    Expectations are bad. Somebody said these guys were for fans of Precious Death and Galactic Cowboys. Sure, if you don't mind taking away most of the musical ability, song-writing skills, and intelligent lyrics. What's left? Heavy guitars and standard aggro-alternative vocals. Not bad, not good, just there. The production is crisp and the guitar tone has plenty of crunch, but they fail to raise any interest in this hardened hard music fan.

    The title cut, "My Daddy Can Whip Your Daddy," proclaims "God is good, God is good, He's so freakin' awesome," and then wraps up with the totally unnecessary repetition of the song's title in reference to Christianity vs. other religions. It may be true, but that's hardly the way to evangelize (unfortunately, the disc ends with the same haughty tone). One dull, repetitive track follows, then an okay acoustic tune with "Fill My Shoes." Next is an okay grunge song. Finally, you get "Easter Bunny," about rebuking social religion (Santa & the Bunny) in favor of celebrating Christ instead (which I'd still consider social religion, but no time for that here). It's kind of a catchy tune.

    Overall, I'd say this 18-minute EP is a slight improvement over their indie debut (almost entirely due to production), but it'll take a couple more albums before I become a disciple of this band.

    2.5 tocks

    Similar sounding releases

    1999NailedEntity2004Project 86Songs To Burn Your Bridges By2005StapleOf Truth and Reconciliation1994King's XDogman2003SkilletCollide1997TourniquetCrawl to China

    More from Disciple

    2005Disciple2003Back Again1990Paradise2001By God1993Demo 931999This Might Sting a Little

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1997

    1997Model EngineThe Lean Years Tradition1997Dream TheaterFalling into Infinity1996Lies Damned LiesLamentations1997GuardianBottle Rocket1999Various ArtistsSoul Survivor - The People's Album1997Trammell StarksSanctuary