The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1997/Sue Rinaldi
    Sue Rinaldi — Promise Land cover

    Sue Rinaldi

    Promise Land

    (1998)

    Reviewed by James Stewart

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label Survivor RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth1997
    pop rockworship

    From a brief appearance in the UK charts in the late 80s with Heartbeat, to leading worship at Wembley Stadium last year, Sue Rinaldi can hardly be accused of keeping a low profile in British Christian circles. This is her second solo effort, and follows 1994's Love Eternal, an album that is perhaps better passed over....

    From the first track it is easy to see that the production values are higher on this project than on its predecessor. The arrangements are stronger here, although still not great. The material is a mix of worship and performance-oriented material, but it may prove difficult for some to use in worship because of Sue's rather unusual voice.

    That voice seems to be one that people either love or hate. In places she actually sounds quite masculine, but mostly she's on the deep end of the female vocal scale. Her voice often sounds a little strained also, which is a shame. Musically, I really like the laid-back "Time And Again," a song with a drum machine beat and gentle sounds scattered on top, but the vocals don't seem to fit the instrumentation terribly well - not ethereal enough.

    The songs vary from the delirious? and brit-pop-influenced sound of the opener, to some seemingly mellow, Portishead-influenced sounds that are mixed in. The arrangements do tend to be a bit dry and stretched out, although there are some strings added in places for a little variety, and some nice guitar arpeggios popping up now and then.

    delirious? definitely seems to have been an influence on Sue's songwriting, both musically and lyrically, as do Noel Richards and Matt Redman -- their influences aren't overwhelming but certainly do crop up.

    Lyrically, the album mixes songs filled with wonder, excitement, and looking to Christ's return. The lyrics are fairly well-written, with a number of hooks to allow people to sing along, but in places I feel they suffer from being too simplistic, and I'm not sure how appropriate I'd find them in a worship setting.

    The particular movement within the church that Sue Rinaldi is involved in is very interested in the idea of 'revival,' and that is a theme which crops up throughout this album. This is particularly clear on "Redemption Street." Focusing on a drum machine-driven beat and the occasional guitar lick before bringing in lightly distorted, driving guitar on the chorus, the song will probably do well at youth gatherings with its sing-along lyrics:

    Let's go down to Redemption Street
    The lost are found at Redemption Street
    Let's go down to Redemption Street
    Come and drink from the well at Redemption Street

    The standout track is probably the next one, "Lay Myself Down." It is an atmospheric song with only keyboard swirls really audible for most of the song:

    I will follow You to the cross
    And lay myself down, lay myself down
    Rid me of these dirty clothes
    Cleanse me from all this pollution
    I choose to walk in purity
    Purify me, purify me

    Overall, however, this album is very patchy. There are some good ideas and combinations of ideas, but none of the songs really shine, and most of the chord progressions are a little tired. Maybe some of them will translate live, but here they are nothing more than average.

    2.5 tocks

    Similar sounding releases

    2000Michelle TumesCenter Of My Universe2005Sinéad O'ConnorCollaborations1997Rebecca St. JamesChristmas1998Sinead LohanNo Mermaid1998Margaret BeckerFalling Forward1998Trembling Blue StarsLips That Taste of Tears

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1997

    1997Satellite SoulSatellite Soul1997Various ArtistsCanticle of the Plains1997Janine StangeOne Way1996Vigilantes of LoveV.O.L.1997BuckStops Here!1997EPAJewel Box