The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1999/Smalltown Poets
    Smalltown Poets — Listen Closely cover

    Smalltown Poets

    Listen Closely

    (1998)

    Reviewed by Keith Giles

    DiscogsBandcampApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label ForeFront RecordsThe Phantom Tollbooth1999
    acoustic rockalternative rockccmjangle pop

    For fans of a lighter Jars of Clay or a less funky DC Talk, this second release from Smalltown Poets is for you.

    Michael Johnston, former vocalist and guitarist from Villanelle, returns with a second set of radio-friendly tunes. His lyrics are still some of the very best that Christian music has to offer when it comes to the confessional, 'cut to the quick' brand of writing. For example, on the song "48 States" he sings:

    Been to 48 states and a few different worlds
    I've seen dithered men leave boys, women, and girls
    Found the Church roll full and they're current with dues
    To pay for the empty pews...

    Lyrics as cutting and brutally honest as these can be found liberally throughout, couched alongside nice harmonies and the crisp and clean guitars.

    Perhaps it's this dichotomy that is so unsatisfying at times. When words like

    Petty daggers bounce weakly off my back
    I'm leaving breathless gods and secrets in my tracks
    Your wishes set in stone, I borne the first often
    I've cleared this temple out come take your place again

    are sung to such sweet, pop music, the sour truth they speak of can become lost in all the sugar.

    Honestly, if you don't dig deep enough to sit down with the lyric sheets and read what's being sung, you won't come away with the full impact of this complex musical package.

    3 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    The Lighthouse Unsorted 1999Reviewed by Bert GanglThe intelligent and spirited alternative pop/rock of Smalltown Poets' self-titled debut made it an unqualified success. The album generated two #1 singles, received both Billboard and Grammy award nominations, and was the fastest selling debut in Forefront Records' history. For the most part, the group's follow-up, Listen Closely, is built upon the same modern rock and pop framework as the debut.…The Phantom Tollbooth 1999Reviewed by James Stewart"You're about to hear sounds that are a little different to what you're accustomed to" proclaims a voice at the start of the tenth track of Smalltown Poets' sophomore album. But to be honest, I don't know why, since there's nothing in this track or the album that hasn't been heard before. The Poets sound like any acoustic band gone electric, and the production, like most of ForeFront's output, is…

    Similar sounding releases

    1999Satellite SoulGreat Big Universe1998The NormalsBetter Than This2004PivitplexUnder Museum Quality Glass1997Toad the Wet SprocketCoil2001LaRueTransparent1995The WaitingBlue Belly Sky

    More from Smalltown Poets

    1997Smalltown Poets2004It's Later Than It's Ever Been2000Third Verse

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1999

    1998Ashen MortalityYour Caress1999The Latin PlayboysDose1997Deezer DLivin Up in a Down Word1999Hokus PickSuper Duper1999Faith MassiveVisions1999Various ArtistsFools Rush In Where Angels Dare Not Tread