The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998/The Hope Blister
    The Hope Blister — smile's ok cover

    The Hope Blister

    smile's ok

    (1998)

    Reviewed by James Stewart

    DiscogsBandcampApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label 4ADThe Phantom Tollbooth1998
    ambientdarkwavedream pop

    Not so much a band as a collection of musicians who've come together in the studio to reinterpret a set of other artist's songs, The Hope Blister is described by 4AD records as "...sort of a sequel to This Mortal Coil." It is also a welcome return to the studio from label founder Ivo Watts-Russell.

    The music harks back to the old school of 4AD bands, with strong female vocals over an ethereal sound-scape. This Mortal Coil featured a large collection of musicians, but this is a smaller group. The majority of the playing comes from Laurence O'Keefe (bass guitar), Audrey Riley (cello), Chris Tombling and Leo Payne (violins), Sue Dench (viola) and Ritchie Thomas (saxophone and drums). The lead vocals come from the very talented Louise Rutkowski (one of the Rutkowski twins involved in later This Mortal Coil recordings); she is supported by a range of backing vocalists. While her vocals aren't quite as spine-tingling as label-mate Lisa Gerrard, nor as world-weary as Kristin Hersh, her voice is well suited to the music and her inflections show elements of both of these other singers. The other musicians bring such a range of sounds to the mix that it is difficult to believe most of this was created by such a small range of instruments. Although this is a sparse record, with the strings and bass guitar dominating, it feels like there is more there than there actually is. This approach certainly works in the producer's favor and the listener is drawn in without being overwhelmed with sonic intricacies.

    The first track up, 'Dagger,' is also featured on this year's 4AD compilation Anakin and is the most immediate and commercially mixed offering on the album. Originally by Neil Halstead (currently of Mojave 3), this song could be a successful single if things worked out properly; however, this is not a radio-friendly recording overall and success is never guaranteed in such a fickle industry. Other tracks offer a variety of interpretations of some of the producer's chosen songs. For example, Brian Eno's "Spider And I" is covered with an abundance of treble provided mainly by the violins and viola and some of the highest pitched vocals on the album. I was intrigued by the track named "Is Jesus Your Pal," another melancholy song among many such songs on this album. Musically it is a dark, foreboding piece with a droning string section underpinning the work, almost accusatory vocals, and sounds like pneumatic drills crossing with ringing bells hiding in the background of the mix. It will also surely intrigue those who enjoy exploring the ambiguities of lyrics:

    Is Jesus your pal?
    Do you call on his name?
    When your conscience is shivering
    Do you need someone too?
    Just like those people who
    Find peace in someone's promises
    You sure don't need my promises

    This is yet another interesting release from 4AD, and while it is certainly artistically stronger than most releases, I am still left slightly dissatisfied. Too many of these arrangements are self indulgent. Nevertheless, it is still a good album to kick back and relax to, and is hopefully a hint of something slightly more focused to come from this group in the future.

    4 tocks

    Similar sounding releases

    2002Black Tape for a Blue GirlScavenger Bride1995SlowdivePygmalion1999Sigur RósÁgætis Byrjun2003PetracovichBlue Cotton Skin2003NamelessnumberheadmanYour Voice Repeating2003Ursula BurnsRollercoaster Castaway

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1998

    1998Eric ChampionNatural1996PreachaGeography of a Journey1998Shawn ColvinHoliday Songs and Lullabies1997Last ChapterThe Living Waters1997CruciferaeThe Light Prevails1998SoulflySoulfly