The Lost Archives Surfacing the reviews of our forgotten youth
    Back to The Lost Archives
    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998/The Waiting
    The Waiting — Blue Belly Sky cover

    The Waiting

    Blue Belly Sky

    (1995)

    Reviewed by Jerry Ray

    DiscogsApple MusicTIDALAmazon MusicSpotifyYouTube Music
    Label R.E.X. MusicThe Phantom Tollbooth1998
    alternative rockccmpop rockpower pop

    In an apparent attempt to capitalize on the success of 1997's The Waiting, Sparrow has reissued the band's 1995 effort Blue Belly Sky, originally released on REX Music. The new version has been digitally remastered (though this listener can't hear a difference) and features four new tracks and new packaging.

    For those unfamiliar with The Waiting, the band hails from Atlanta, Georgia and falls generally into the same pop/rock category as fellow Atlantans Third Day and Smalltown Poets. Fortunately, their sound is also unique enough to separate them from the pack of pop/rockers in the market today, even in a set of songs recorded nearly 5 years ago.

    Singer Brad Olsen's vocals are unconventional but pleasant and don't bring to mind any good comparisons. His half-spoken approach is particularly effective on songs like "Look at Me" and "Staring at a Bird."

    Lyrically, the band uses some familiar imagery and some catchy phrasings to paint pictures clearly, and in a way that you can sing along to. In "Look at Me," Brad Olsen and brother/guitarist Todd Olsen write:

    I love the way You look at me, the way You steer Your eyes
    To see the bride beneath the harlot's skin, the virtue underneath the sin
    I love the way You look at me, when You lift the veil
    And You repeat Your vow

    Musically, The Waiting utilizes a nice mix of acoustic guitars and jangly electrics on most tracks, with the occasional noisy alterna-guitar thrown in for good measure. There's just a trace of an Irish sound that pops up in the melodies here and there that contributes to the uniqueness of the band's sound. The bulk of the album consists of upbeat, rocky songs, but slower, worshipful songs like "Mercy Seat" and "Is This the Day" provide a bit of variety. The whole album is quite melodic, perfectly suited for singing along with the windows down on a summer drive.

    The lyrics and music work together exceptionally well on "Israel." The Olsens write "Call me Israel/Since some years ago, it's been my fate to sail November seas," while the music and Olsen's delivery call to mind a sailor's chantey to produce one of the album's highlights.

    The four new tracks are somewhat hit-or-miss; two of the tracks don't add much to the disc, while the other two turn out to be two of the highlights. All four fit well into the rest of the album stylistically, though they feature somewhat more adventurous guitar sounds than the older tracks.

    "Still So Pretty" is a fairly bland "list of city names with a chorus" song. "Nobody's Love" doesn't seem to really take flight, either. The band turns in two great tracks in "I Want You Back" (yes, a cover of the Jackson 5 song) and "Charming One." What sort of message is to be found in "I Want You Back"? Well, not much of one, but it's a fun song and showcases the sort of fun cover songs that the band includes in their live sets. "Charming One" is an outstanding track, with a bit of an Eastern flavor by way of the Georgia Satellites (co-written by Steve Hindalong, to boot).

    For people who already own the original Blue Belly Sky, this reissue is probably not essential but the new tracks are at least worth demoing. For everyone else, I highly recommend this disc, which I personally enjoy more than the band's self-titled followup. This is a strong effort, despite the fact that it comes from early in the band's career.

    4.5 tocks

    Other coverage for this album

    The Phantom Tollbooth 1998Reviewed by James StewartFollowing the success of their self-titled album, The Waiting's record label have decided that it is time to re-issue this, their previous indie release with a new track order and four new tracks. Production wise I can't really choose between this and The Waiting, although this is slightly rawer. Never having really gotten into that album, I was pleasantly surprised to find myself gradually…

    Similar sounding releases

    2000Paul Colman TrioTurn1995Dime Store ProphetsLove Is Against The Grain1997Smalltown PoetsSmalltown Poets1998Send the BeggarSend the Beggar1997TreeOverflow2000Chris TaylorWorthless Pursuit of Things On the Earth

    More from The Waiting

    2001Wonderfully Made1997The Waiting

    Also in The Phantom Tollbooth 1998

    1997The Way Sect BloomEffloresce1998StormStorm1998PsaltersPrayers to Be1998Richard BucknerSince1998Eso-CharisEso-Charis1998PolarboyBack From Nowhere