Within two minutes of my first Vigilantes of Love live show ending, I had run across the field and bought an album. Bill Mallonee's passionate music and incisive lyrics won me over instantly, and I wanted to hold something of this with me when the festival was over.
It's a couple of albums later, and my enthusiasm hasn't waned. The band has now gone indie, cutting all ties with old record labels and management in an effort to re-establish themselves. And they've added a fourth member--Kenny Hutson--on second guitar, pedal steel, lap steel and mandolin. He brings more texture to the arrangements, and helps the band refer back to the more rootsy sound of Killing Floor, while building in influences from the alterna-country movement.
Musically, this album has some rough edges, but in some ways gains from them--this is a band that is meant to sound raw. In a few places Mallonee's vocals are a little awkward, but most of the time they're the impassioned and individual vocals that we have come to expect. The title track features some spine-tingling pedal steel, and "The Opposite's True" must be a favorite live; it sounds like a crowd pleaser that'd have them up and dancing.
The introduction to "Perishable Goods" almost sounds like something from Sixpence None the Richer's This Beautiful Mess. The one thing the album is missing is some all-out rockers. The first track, "But Not for Long," has the makings of this, but isn't quite tight enough to fully take advantage of that direction.
Sometimes the songs are a little long, the extra repetition of the title crops up a few times too many, and fans of concept albums may miss the themes that have sometimes been found in Vigilantes of Love albums. It is obvious, though, that the band has relished the opportunity to record the album they wanted to, and this is a fine addition to the collection.
4 tocks
Other coverage for this album
The Phantom Tollbooth 1998Reviewed by Steven S. BaldwinTo the Roof of the Sky is Bill Mallonee and company's middle of the road musical memoirs and features a more acquired alt-country taste with less feisty fare than their previous three albums. If you're looking for loads of rowdy songs like "Undertow," "Resume," "Five Miles South of Monroe," or "Locust Years" you won't find as many of 'em. Instead, what you'll get is a panoply of accessible,…The Phantom Tollbooth 1998Reviewed by Linda T. StonehockerSooner or later, we all do what we must, Sooner or later, it comes down to trust. . . Sooner or later, we all become what we chose, Sooner or later, truth be told. (From "Paralyzed") Life is difficult, but as the Vigilantes of Love conclude repeatedly on one of their most balanced, best produced projects to date, survivable. To the Roof of the Sky was written by a mature, balanced grownup wise in…Similar sounding releases
2003Bill MalloneeLocket Full of Moonlight
1997Tonio K.Ole
2004Peter HimmelmanUnstoppable Forces
1999Lost DogsThe Best of the Lost Dogs
1999A Ragamuffin BandPrayers of a Ragamuffin
2004Trevor MorganWonderlightMore from Vigilantes of Love
2001Summershine
1998Live at the 40 Watt
2004Fade to Black (Video)
Killing Floor
1995Blister Soul
1994Welcome To Struggleville
